5 Reasons Not To Give Up Something for Lent

In the not-trying-to-bash-legalistsArtistic Orthodox intepretation of Resurrection-but-kinda category, this from ThinkChristian. Here’s the first three reasons not to give up something for Lent. Please visit ThinkChristian for reasons number 4 and 5.

BTW, although this is great humor as well, salvation is serious business. I pray some seeds are planted here.

Five Reasons Not To Give Up Something for Lent

Posted March 5th @ 7:00 am by Nathan

For Lent, I’m giving up the idea of giving up something for Lent. There are some good reasons to do it, but I can think of a few reasons not to.

1. It’s Not the Self-Denial Olympics
If the point of giving up something for Lent is nothing more than self-congratulation for feats of abstinence, I’m not interested. Fasting, in centuries of monastic practice, is only worthwhile as far as it increases your spiritual focus, your meditation, your awareness of utter dependence on God. In our diet-happy culture, simply avoiding something is itself an accomplishment, a triumph of willpower and demonstration of self-control that ironically gives you a higher, not a lower, view of yourself. “The New Testament has lots to say about self-denial, but not about self-denial as an end in itself,” said C.S. Lewis in his timeless sermon “The Weight of Glory.”

“We are told to deny ourselves and to take up our crosses in order that we may follow Christ,” Lewis continued. Which brings me to #2.

2. Chocolate Ain’t a Cross
I have friends giving up chocolate, or alcohol, or TV, or ice cream, for Lent. I admire their sacrifices. But, those are still pretty trivial sacrifices. I’d be more impressed if people gave up not a minor indulgence, but a supposed non-negotiable of modern life. Driving. E-mail. Mirrors. Consumer goods produced more than 100 miles from your house.

That would impress me. But I still don’t think it would impress God. “Take up your cross and follow me.” It’s a call to complete self-emptying.

3. We’re Not Trying To Beat Christ at His Own Game
Sometimes, I wonder if giving up something for Lent comes out of a twinge of guilt about Jesus’ suffering— “Jesus went through so much pain for me, the least I can do in return is keep my hand out of the cookie jar for a month.” First, Christ endured hell precisely so that we don’t have to (not that a lack of cookies is hell; see #2 above). He emptied himself in order to invite us to a life of abundance. Not self-indulgence. Not indifference. Not hoarding. But abundance. A life of fasting and feasting.

Be sure to finish reading four and five here…and a great closing argument.


One thought on “5 Reasons Not To Give Up Something for Lent

  1. Yes, in part, I can see what you mean.”Self Denial Olympics” will have some legalists straining for the self congratulatory finishing tape.
    But for many others taking time out to ease up on some of the comforts of every day life could aid thier pre-Easter spirituality.
    I attend a Pentecostal church where we have never observed Lent until now. Our new seniorleader has introduced the concept and I’m sure it will give many of us a greater sense of the poignacy of Easter. I prefer the idea of fasting objectives to be personal rather than advertised for all to see. Its between me and God. Already as I observe Lent in a small way, I sense the possibility of insight and healing for a new year.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s